Wednesday 20 March 2024

70 YEARS OF THE MILL HILL MUSICAL THEATRE COMPANY


A Guest blog by Claire Shah - MHMTC Chair

As Mill Hill Musical Theatre Company gears up to mark its 70th anniversary in 2024, we look to pay tribute to our operatic past, celebrate a present based in musical theatre sorely tested during lockdown, and strive to forge an exciting future that hopefully will see us around for another 70 years. 

We are lucky that we have an archive of material to review and are able to tap the memories of our President Grant Graves. His parents, Richard and Margery, formed Mill Hill Amateur Operatic Society (as it was originally known) in 1954, riding the crest of a post-war wave for live entertainment. Professional theatre had been decimated during the war, and there wasn’t much competition from other forms of leisure, with just one TV channel (ITV would come in 1955), three radio stations and, if you could afford it, cinema.  

 

Our first production, Gilbert & Sullivan’s satirical operetta The Gondoliers, was then itself 65 years old. A great success it was followed by Lilac Time and My Lady Jennifer, a mix of other G&S favourites, and the likes of The Merry Widow, La Vie Parisienne, Die Fledermaus and La Belle Helene.  Featuring large casts and bolstered by sell-out performances, the classics of the genre would form the backbone of the society.  

 


The full-blown productions were graced with amazing costumes and hand-made scenery and props constructed by Richard Graves and his talented team, including a collapsible grand piano for Bitter Sweet and a grand curving staircase for Perchance To Dream.  In the late 1950s, we began organising smaller social gatherings, accompanied by cheese and wine, which gave everyone a chance to do some more singing, and especially allowing chorus members to take centre stage. It also provided an additional opportunity to build our Patron numbers. 
 

 

Little did we know that these informal spring “Patrons’ Parties” would morph into somewhat bigger and more involved affairs, serving as a huge thank you to our Patrons for their invaluable support. They do, however, retain an intimate quality, which the cast enjoy as much as the larger shows. In addition, these revues encourage the less experienced or anxious member to build up confidence and enjoyment by taking on anything from a couple of solo lines to verses and even songs. We’ve had many young members go on after these Patrons’ Parties to audition for – and secure – parts in a main show. 

 

Moving into the 1960s, the focus – and the bulk of the budget – was still very much on the main shows. The group now used an orchestra rather than two pianos as at the outset with a young cast – some of whom are still with the Company to this day. The audiences were mainly from Mill Hill, and there were many groups who would block book performances in those days, notably the Church Women’s Guild, the WI, The Townswomen’s Guild, the Rotary Club, the Cottage Homes groups and the Anglo-American Club (though the latter were a noticeable no show on the night JKF was shot).  

 

One of the most crucial aspects of MHAOS that helped keep cast, Patrons and audiences committed was that the productions were excellently staged and performed. In the 1970s Orpheus And The Underworld, Princess Ida and Merrie England were staged for the first time. We would regularly get double-page spreads in the local press, which, added to excellent word of mouth, ensured shows were well attended. There was also always a rush by the cast to read the reviews garnered in the likes of Mill Hill Times 

 


As the 1980s approached, there seemed to be a pervasive shift in attitude from supporting amateur theatre to wanting to watch the professionals – either on screen or in the West End.  Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice were foremost in reinvigorating musical theatre. As a result, and during the relatively short and forward-thinking chairmanship of Sue Graves, we began sampling the likes of The Boy Friend and Salad Days within our Patrons’ Parties. It’s fair to say, that this was a seismic shift for MHAOS. 
 

 

However, within the Society, operettas remained a firm favourite, with stalwarts Gipsy Baron, Veronique, Tom Jones and the G&S hits getting repeated airings. Having the multi-talented Margaret Dewar as our accompanist was a big bonus (she also taught some of the casts tap dances routine on occasion). However, even the most popular and grand operettas suffered from casting difficulties – even for well-known Strauss’ Die Fledermaus, finding a strong tenor for the main role was becoming increasingly difficult (a recurring theme!).  

 

Turning into the Noughties, the committee continued to weigh up casting and audience appeal when choosing main shows – something that is still the case to this day. With a large and supportive group of Patrons, operettas remained our stock in trade. Musically we were still strong, with the baton having been handed to another group of engaging younger principals, although as is the case for lots of societies, these were mostly women, with the men still being in short supply. We were still satisfying our Patrons and our core audiences, but numbers were contracting, including on stage, with older members retiring and some younger cast settling down to  family life.  

 

I joined the Society in 2001, keen to get back on stage after a short break following my time in my university’s G&S Society. Coincidentally, my first show with MHAOS was The Gondoliers – our debut back in 1954 – and somehow, I was persuaded to direct the Patrons’ Party the very next year. In double-quick time, the group became a very big part of my life.  

 

While Grant was Chairman, the focus had turned to MHAOS being financially secure enough to withstand at least one financial failure if necessary. Thankfully, that never transpired, helped in part by having prudent treasurers. This cushion stood us in good stead, allowing us to make some bold decisions in the difficult years ahead. 

 

Audience numbers were dwindling. Primarily filled with our Patrons, the Gala performances, on Fridays and Saturdays, were always well attended and had a festive atmosphere with a light supper served during the interval. Those performances were always amazing, with a warm audience always appreciative of our efforts. The other nights were hit and miss – and when only 16 people attended opening night one cold Tuesday in October, it was clear to the committee, led by Chairman Chris Hubbard, that a shake-up was required.  

 

In 2008, the Tuesday night show was axed in favour of a Saturday matinee. However, in 2011, to improve audience numbers and to help with casting shows from within our membership, we made our first major foray into musical theatre.  

 

Our first show of that genre was an easy pick – Guys And Dolls, an iconic smash hit from a different era with a contrasting, more vibrant feel – a huge move away from operetta. Originally planned for autumn of 2010, it was moved to April 2011 due to a licensing issue: another break with tradition as our main shows had always taken place in the autumn half-term because many of our founding members were teachers.  

 

For the first time the Society advertised externally for a director and MD. We hit the jackpot with Robin Scarborough as director and music student James Murray as MD. We also threw a launch night, through which we secured some new members. It was a huge success – every performance sold out.  

 

It was a new era in more ways than one, as it was also our final production in the old Hartley Hall, which had been our much-loved home for 57 years. It was idiosyncratic, draughty and aged, but had a great stage, decent rehearsal rooms and loads of storage for our sets and props. We were also blessed that we could use it to build and paint our sets, a team effort lead by our clever stage manager Dave Smith, with Jill Kelly lending her artistic talents on painting. However, our noble Edwardian stalwart was to be replaced by a new community hub, complete with modern amenities and performance space.  

 

We therefore had the problem of locating a new base to rehearse and perform in for an estimated three years on a very limited budget. We found a temporary home at John Keble Church, slightly outside of Mill Hill – and, although we managed to stage three Patrons’ Parties there, it was not possible to perform a main show there in the autumn due to its arrangements with other long-standing users.  

 

In 2012, St Michael and All Angels Church, Mill Hill, played host for our spring event – a semi-staged production of HMS Pinafore which benefitted hugely from the building’s wonderful acoustics. Upbeat Broadway classic Kiss Me, Kate was to be our next autumn show, and after much searching, Copthall School (our half-term show dates working in our favour) in Mill Hill East was chosen as the venue.  

 

Our main issue with the loss of Hartley Hall, was not having a space to construct a set. Long-term member Angus Henney generously gave the use of his garage and driveway, where our set designer, Rob Barker (also our lighting director for many years), devised an ingenious set of reversible backdrops and flats. However, as Rob was in New York for much of this period, most of the work was carried out by cast and committee. Following his hand-written instructions was a challenge to say the least, with calls going back and forth to the US for clarification – plus, the weather definitely wasn’t on our side! Luckily everything came together and Kiss Me, Kate did very well – we were delighted to receive some lovely feedback from our Patrons about how enjoyable it was.  

 

Not having a proper base at this time made us very aware how lucky we had been in Hartley Hall and long for its return! We made the difficult decision not to find another venue to perform a main show in 2013 and opted to come back with a bang in the new Hartley Hall for our 60th anniversary in 2014.  

 

In 2013, we had made official our intention to move away from operetta clear by changing our name to Mill Hill Musical Theatre Company, and also updated our ancient website. While most people were supportive for this update, sadly we couldn’t hang on to some long-term members, who only wanted to sing the more classical songs. 

 

Wanting to celebrate our birthday with a real crowd-pleaser and mark our return to full strength with a vengeance, we chose Oliver! – including children in the cast would mean lots of their families and friends in the audience! It did throw up a lot of new and interesting issues, however, with the need for chaperones and extra rehearsals.   

 

It was a nervous time, as we awaited news of Hartley Hall’s reopening, even going as far as to pencilling in dates at an alternate venue. Thankfully, Hartley Hall was ready a few weeks before curtain up. While vastly different from the old hall – no wings and a much lower stage than previously – it looked great. We did, however, have a steep learning curve getting used to the new hall and using a hired set – we no longer had space to build or store one – and using microphones for the first time. 

 

Calamity Jane followed in 2015 and, although successful, some members wanted to return to the occasional operetta – the saving in not needing a performance licence was a definite bonus. In 2016, we staged The Pirates Of Penzance but, despite the cast having a great time, ticket sales were sluggish, and we had to reduce prices, including a two-for-one deal. The first night was notably problematic, as some of the cast and half the orchestra got caught up in a terrible traffic jam around north-west London and didn’t make it for curtain-up!  

 

Financially disappointed with our return to operetta, Sister Act was chosen as our 2017 production. An ambitious musical, there was plenty to keep the committee busy, but it did attract lots of new members – most of whom are still with us today. We were also lucky in finding the perfect and most simple set ever, from A1 Staging – giving us wings at long last!!  

 

The biggest difficulty we had, though, was getting an MD. With such a complicated score, it took a while to find someone willing and able to help. Thankfully everything worked out and the show was a total joy. The cast thoroughly enjoyed every minute, we sold out every performance well in advance of show week and received standing ovations every night. It was a big turning point for us.  

However, we still had people living in Mill Hill who said they didn’t know we existed. We decided to take a serious look at how we promoted ourselves, and make use of social media, etc, going forward. We know it is vital in raising our profile – attracting not just audiences but fresh blood to join the mix of more experience cast stalwarts who are the backbone of the Company. 

 

Moving to 2018, Fiddler On The Roof proved another huge hit, with every performance sold out, helped by the large Jewish community in Mill Hill. Through David Rose, who played Tevye, we secured the directing talents of David Coleman, who is now a great friend and supporter of MHMTC, having helmed two other shows for us. The production issues, however, included negotiating another massive set. Getting the cottage roof down a flight of stairs (it wouldn’t fit through the narrow stage hatch), was no mean feat – taking eight of us to ease it around several tight corners, avoiding various fire alarms, light fittings and a slanted ceiling! Pivot!

 

With a view to keeping our more traditional supporters happy, we staged Oklahoma! in 2019. At this stage, we were in a comfortable position financially and with our membership. But then things changed for us dramatically, as indeed they did for the entire country in March 2020, when we cancelled our spring Patrons’ Party weeks away from curtain up and went into lockdown. 

 

We had decided to postpone the week before lockdown was announced due to great concern from our audience, and some of the cast, regarding the spread of the virus. Little did we know at this point that the restrictions would last as long as they did, or that the pandemic would impact everyone’s lives for such a long time. We did, however, want to ensure that the Company stayed part of people’s live and routines during these unusual times. We therefore continued to meet each week on our rehearsal nights – through the miracle of Zoom – and staged play readings, bingo nights and quizzes. Eventually, we met up in the park when allowed to do so – socially distanced, of course! 

 

Prior to lockdown, we had chosen Made In Dagenham as our next main show. During that period, it became clear casting (unsurprisingly the male roles) would be problematic. We felt it was important to choose a well-known and loved show to encourage members to take part and audiences to come and watch! The obvious choice was Guys And Dolls – and proved to be an incredibly pragmatic and fortuitous decision. Still under heavy constraints, with the rule of six, etc, we held auditions without practising, staggered rehearsals with cast waiting outside rooms until they could go in, wore masks in the hall for the note-bashing, and taught choreography over Zoom – thankfully people had missed it so much, they were willing to endure these rules. 

 

We were also hugely fortunate to have the support of our Mill Hill community, both at Hartley Hall and the Sacred Heart church opposite. The latter was especially useful in that we had access to a large screen and projector which we could use for people isolating to join/lead rehearsals – this was especially vital when a month before the show, three of the lead principals (one of whom was also choreographer) all tested positive. As we wanted to make our audience feel as safe as possible, we reduced the capacity in the hall to allow for distancing. We were delighted that we sold out every performance and the atmosphere in the hall every night was electric. 

 

Kiss Me, Kate in 2022 was also a winner for us, playing out to packed houses, and garnering overwhelmingly positive feedback. We didn’t believe it was the right time to push a very modern show, or something we didn’t know would work. We felt we were building our brand and the audience’s trust that they would get a good night out, even if we put on something riskier.  

 

I became chair in 2021, taking over from Chris Hubbard, who had steered the Company through the rockiest time in our history, overseeing many changes with a steady hand. We all admire and acknowledge the diligent, unwavering work she did.  

 

I knew MHMTC still had a lot of work to do in attracting young cast members, changing perceptions, and making it a modern, slick outfit. We drew up a three-year-plan to take us a step closer to reaching that goal each year. Kiss Me, Kate was the launch point, with 9 To 5 the second step in 2023. We are hopeful that the iconic title track and the movie, plus the redoubtable Dolly Parton will attract a younger crowd, while keeping older audiences happy. 

 


For our 70th anniversary year, I was keen to stage a musical that would repeat the Sister Act effect for both our membership and audience. Calendar Girls: The Musical is that show! It’s definitely a leap into the unknown for us – and quite a test logistically – but the story is truly uplifting.
 We are delighted that Robin Scarborough is returning as director, working with our super-talented resident MD Ricardo Fernandes (who joined us in 2019). We can’t wait to get started! 

 

Our 2024 Patrons’ Party, Our Platinum Years, will be a chance to celebrate 70 years of the good songs and the wonderful shows we’ve done, while a special one-off performance in June of G&S staple Ruddigore will allow us to show old and current members where it all started.

 

Staging three shows in one year will be a challenge, with rehearsals for Calendar Girls and Ruddigore running at the same time – and not forgetting our quizzes and bingo and some festive social events for cast and Patrons. We are under no illusions that it is going to be a huge amount of hard work for the committee (and the cast), but we are also convinced that our MHMTC family and its future is worth every moment.  

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Guest blogs are always welcome, especially when they support local arts and culture.

No comments: