Alan Schneiderman - Parking changes too little too late

Footage from last nights council meeting. Alan Scniederman dismisses parking announcement as "too little, too late"


Thanks top TheMarathon28 for footage

Barnet Council - Budget and Performance Overview and Scrutiny Committee Meeting - 06/12/11

So yet again we find ourselves in Hendon Town Hall  for yet another Council meeting where it seems as if the officers and councillors of Barnet Council live in a completely different dimension from the rest of us. If I hadn't spent 3 1/2 years writing a blog, and tonights meeting was the first ever exposure to Barnet I'd had, I'd probably think Barnet was the best Borough in the multiverse.

For me, the highlight was Councillor John Marshalls comments about Biran Coleman. These are on video and we'll save them for the Friday joke !

So what were the highlights. For Labour, Alan Schneiderman was running the show (and this he did pretty well, ably assisted by his boss Alison Moore).

Here's a few of his direct hits.

He asked why Barnet Council only had a target of 80% for compliance for the TOP 50 vendors, with Barnet's purchasing rules.

Deputy Leader Andrew Travers hit back with a stinging reply that "70% by value are already compliant". Even more bizarrely Councillor Brian Gordon chipped in to say that some Councils had  a zero compliance rate, so Barnet must be marvellous. I was sitting more or less next  to Leader Richard Cornelius at this point. As Gordon spoke (on video), Richard obviously thought "please mother earth, swallow me up" or words to that effect.

The next goal Schniederman scored was to ask about the fact that Barnet is failing to meet its legal requirements for FOI requests. An officer replied that "perfomance is improving and the number of requests is going up". He explained that they are working hard to close the backlog of "difficult (to who) requests".

Councillor Stronglou suggested that clean recyclables be collected once a month to save money. The Leader couldn't make up his mind whether this was a good or bad idea. Labour Leader Alison Moore said it would send out all the wrong messages. The leader said he was completely against changing form a once a week bin collection, but other options may be considered. The Councillor Cornelius made a startling admission. He'd recently caught Dom Joly going through his bin for a TV show. Since then he's been very circumspect about what he'd put in it? If I was him I'd demand a parliamentary enquiry. A free pot noodle for anyone who can locate the clip.

A Council officer revealed that Empower Consultancy had been paid £65,000 to produce a report detailing what colour our bins should be and how they should be collected. I believe that is the services of one bloke for just over a month, to write a report with a couple of lovely graphs in. Sadly, there are two youth services officers I know who were made redundant on salaries that would have paid for a year.

The we had the most depressing part of the evening, A discussion of care packages and personal budgets. Step forward Councillor Gordon. He didn't seem to know what a personal care budget was, despite having been on the committee since3 Noah built the Ark (or there abouts). He clearly hadn't read the background papers. His question (and I paraphrase) -  "what happens if someone with a personal budget gets the money and puts it all on laughing boy at the dagenham dog track". Cabinet member Sachin Rajput replied "We have a duty of care to the person, so we'd have to pay again". Rather oddly, Councillor Gordon replied "Marvellous" or words to that effect. But not to worry, Cllr Rajput said. All recipients were monitored every three months and no cases of fraud had made it to Crown Court yet (seriously, that's what he said).

Then we got to One Barnet. Councillor Schneiderman asked why savings had been stated as £26.4 million in one document and £17.9 in another. A Council offiicer replied that £26.4 million was for 10 years and £17.9 was til 2018/19. He then went on to say that the savings were based on the assumption that Barnet Council would do a marvellous job and sell their services to other Boroughs (at that moment a pig flew past the window). Councillor Gordon, listening to this, whilst maintaining a stoney face, developed the most bizarre leg twitch I've ever seen. Clearly his leg has a different view of "One Barnet" to the rest of him. I'm with the leg. The subject of the contract came up. Councillor Marshall stated that two of the bidders were "EC Harris" and "F M Conway". He remarked snottily that they sounded like "firms of solicitors". Councillor Gordon, who runs a firm of solicitors momentarily lost control of the other leg. He also looked like he was going to thump Marshall. Councillor Cornelius stepped in to calm things down by saying "Some firms of solicitors are highly reputable". We sniggered in the public gallery.

Then we got slung out for the "exempt" bit. I earwigged at the door as the voices got raised. Clearly all is not sweetness and light, but then again us mere taxpayers aren't allowed to hear the juicy bits.

And onto parking. Well we will post a rather interesting video here. The debate was surreal. In the public gallery was a bloke from a supplier who didn't win the business. At the end he said "They took five minutes to discuss that. What is going on?". He doesn't really understand Barnet YET does he.

I had a bevvy of hits on the blog from a URL associated with a company that did not win the bid (NCP did). They found the blog with a google search "Barnet council legal action" I did the search myself, this blog is on page 3 for that enquiry. They are clearly doing their homework.

 Perhaps the most telling quote of the night was when Councillor Alison Moore asked "will the council remain in charge of setting the parking charges". Councillor Cornelius replied "Yes" and Councillor Schniederman interjected "Unfortunately".

That is how things are in Barnet.

Barnet Council have learned nothing from the Iceland fiasco

As ever, the devil is in the detail. There is a rather telling exchange detailed in the latest cabinet questions session (question 36), between Alan Schneiderman and the former Leader of Barnet Council. Labour Councillor, Alan Schneiderman had asked why meetings of the Local Strategic partnership were being held in private and what the Council had to hide. He got the following response.

Answer: Leader of the Council
Absolutely nothing. If Councillor Schneiderman actually turned up for some of his Officer briefings, in the past year he actually had half a dozen meetings with Chief Officers, he could actually ask the questions himself. If he actually did the work that he is paid an SRA

Let us remind ourselves of the excuse for Barnet Council losing £27.4 Million pounds in Icelandic banking investment cock ups. When telling Mr Schniederman to ask Council officials he clearly forgot his own excuse for losing the money :-

'Trusting some officers to do their jobs was a mistake'

Read this article in the Edgware Time  - CLICK HERE - for the full story. In it, the former Conservative Council Leader says the following :-

“Sometimes you get let down and you have to learn from the experience.

“If officers can tell me the truth, however problematic that is, you can deal with it. If they don't tell you and it comes out, you have to chop their legs off.

“If you have a finance director and an assistant finance director who are very highly paid and they tell you the procedures have been followed you have a right to rely on them.”

The first sentence is the key. Have Barnet learned from the experience? If the former Council Leader, having lost £27.4 million of our money, because he asked officers questions and they told him porkies, hasn't learned, what hope is there for the rest of them. Schneiderman is right to want to attend the meetings. That way he'll ALL of the information, not just the bits Officers want him to hear. It's called transparency. It works because it helps people to ask proper questions.

I don't care who asks difficult questions at Council, Tory, Labour or Lib Dem. Anyone who wants to stifle debate is no acting in the interests of the people.It is clear to me that until Council Leader Lynne Hillan implements a truly transparent regime at Barnet Council, we will continue to have cock up after Cock up.

Hat Tip to Don't Call Me Dave at Not The Barnet Times foran, Barnet Council, Councillor Lynne Hillan,  highlighting this exchange