Bob the Builder

Bob the builder, can he park here?
Bob the builder, yes he can

This extract comes from a press release on the Barnet Council website

Barnet Council, renowned for its forward thinking parking policies has introduced a proposal to enable builders carrying out works within any Controlled Parking Zone across the borough from April 2009 to apply for a special parking permit. Currently, residents living within Controlled Parking Zones who employ the services of a builder are required to use their allocation of visitor vouchers to avoid penalty charge notices being issued.

Traffic supremo Councillor Andrew Harper has brought the scheme in as a way to help hard pressed tenants and firms. Now from what I've seen of Councillor Harper in action, he seems like a sensible chap, who has a real interest in making Barnet a better place. At the various Council meetings I've attended, if Councillor Harper stands up to say something, it's generally sensible and said in a non confrontational way. I suspect that generally he listens to criticisms and takes things on board.

Well, I'd say that this scheme is what I'd call a "Two cheers for Councillor Harper" scheme. That means that in as far as it goes, it's a good idea, but it could be improved significantly. As I read this press release I thought to myself, Builders and religious leaders can get parking permits under these schemes, but there are plenty of other trades which need to visit homes can't. Let's have a look at the type of people which may require a permit. Gardening contractors, TV repair men, Fridge repair men, voluntary helpers visiting the elderly & disabled. It's not clear to me whether drain cleaners, plumbers, etc are covered.

Here's my suggestion. Rather than lots of seperate schemes, have a scheme for anyone who has a genuine requirement. The recipient of the permit puts it in the front window of their car when they are on business. It has a big number on it and if you see it being abused you report the car to Barnet. If they abuse it they lose it. You fill out an explanation of why you need the permit and if there is a need you pay your fee and get your permit. That's fair and equitable.